Library and Information Science Miscellaneous

This weblog in the field of Library and Information Science contains news, comments and everything that its bloggers think could be useful for LIS professionals and students. It is maintianed by a number of students mainly Research students and Iranian. Our email is lismisblog at Yahoo dot com.

Thursday, September 16, 2004

University Ranking

What Reza reported about Dr. Moein’s words is a ray of hope for us. It’s nice to hear about new scientific promotion of Iranian universities. But we have seen the significant differences between Iranian and other counties’ universities. This big gap should not be forgotten.
Personally, I believe that the main problem with Iranian higher education system is its focusing on education rather than research. As you see in your universities, most academic passion is doing research and publishing new articles not teaching in undergraduate levels. I agree that our system makes the academic people be a teaching machine; however, this does not decrease our responsibility in the case of doing some research.

Several months ago I received a link about Evaluation of the World’s universities (maybe one of you emailed it to me – I can’t remember). This ranking is run every year by a Chinese university. Neither in 2003 nor in 2004 we can’t see any Iranian University among the 500 best universities of the World.
If we consider size of a university as an educational value too, we’ll see that only 20% of the ranking value refers to education and 80% of its authority goes for its research-based statistics and activities:

Criteria / Weight
Quality of Education / 10%
Quality of Faculty / 40%
Research Output / 40%
Size of Institution / 10%
“We have scanned every university that has any Nobel Laureates, Fields Medals, Highly Cited Researchers, or papers published in Nature or Science. In addition, we scanned major universities of every country with significant amount of papers cited by SCIE and SSCI. In total, we have scanned more than two thousand universities” [FAQs].
It seems that the publication and research activities of Iranian universities are very low yet. This is the link for the ranking system mentioned above:
http://ed.sjtu.edu.cn/ranking.htm

2 Comments:

  • At 1:10 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Dear Saeid, I agree with you. But I think the bigger problem is the dissemination of our scientific productions.How many scientific journals do we have? How many of our scientific journals are bilingual? How many of them have been indexed in famous databases? What about dissertations? Is there any policy to disseminate the results of them?

     
  • At 11:09 PM, Blogger saeid said…

    Thank you for your comment. You're right and I agree with you. However we must remember that the number of scientific journals is a resultant of our work. I mean the more we publish the more we'll see quality journals.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home